A Brief History of Commercial Pet Food
|Written by Margaret Gates|
|Monday, September 28, 2009 08:03 AM|
Page 1 of 2
How did we end up feeding corn to cats? Like most people I never really thought much about cat food. It came in cans and bags, and always had, right? After doing a little research, I found out that the whole idea of commercial cat food is relatively new; I just happened to have grown up when it was all in place, so of course for me, it had always been there.
I remember as a child, opening a can of cat food for my cat and having him take one sniff and running away! Canned cat food almost always smelled awful to me, too. I shudder to think what was in it. None of the cats I had as a child lived past 11, and none of them died in accidents, they all got sick. I think what we were feeding them contributed to their ill health.
There are certainly much better cat foods out there now than when I was a child and some of them actually smell rather good. The commercial pet food companies do know a lot more about what cats need, but that still doesn't mean that the pet food industry is making food that is best for your cat.
Cats have been living with humans for a very long time. When people started growing and storing grain, having cats around became a very good idea. Everyone, people and cats, benefited from the arrangement. For almost the entire history of the human-cat relationship cats ate what they could catch — probably thinking how thoughtful it was of the humans to have great piles of rodent attractor around, just to lure their favorite meal right to them — and whatever scraps people would give them. Cats thrived on this primarily fresh caught diet, and rarely suffered from the diseases that are so prevalent today.¹
The commercial pet food industry started in 1860 with James Spratt's invention of the first dog biscuit in England. Made from vegetables, beef blood, wheat, and beet root, Spratt reportedly was inspired by observing sailors throwing hardtack to dogs at the docks. His biscuits were very popular and other companies soon began making their own versions. By 1890, commercial pet food manufacture had spread to the United States.²
It was in the 1900s that commercial pet food really gained popularity. In 1907, F.H. Bennett formed a company in New York City that began making Milk Bone™ dog biscuits. Ken-L-Ration® introduced canned horse meat for dogs after World War I, and Gaines Food® introduced canned cat food and dry meat-meal dog food in the 1930s. During World War II, when metal was rationed (and pet food was classified as "non-essential"), canned pet food wasn't available and the production shifted to dry foods. By 1946, dry food represented 85% of the market.³ At this point there were two kinds of dry food: biscuits, or crumbled biscuits known as kibble, and pellets whose ingredients had to be hand mixed. After World War II, with the economy booming, people could afford the luxury of pet food. In the 1950s and 60s, many companies added pet foods lines to their "human lines" of products. Companies such as General Foods®, Quaker Oats®, Campbell's® Soups, Mars®, Lipton®, Post®, Carnation® and Nabisco® saw pet foods as a profitable way to market by-products.⁴ Most canned cat food at this time was fish.⁵
The next big innovation came in the 1950s with the use of the extrusion process by Purina® (Dog Chow™ and Cat Chow™). The ingredients are cooked together in a liquid form, pushed through a mechanical extruder, which expands the food, and then it is baked.⁶ The end product is larger and lighter than either of the previous methods, which also gave the food a "more for your money" appeal. Convenience was the biggest marketing point with these foods. The foods must contain large amounts of starch for the extrusion process to work. Nutrients are added back in to make up for the loss due to being cooked twice at high temperatures. Fats and flavorings are sprayed on the end product to make them palatable.⁷
Companies began marketing their products as "complete" foods, and started the idea that feeding table scraps was actually dangerous. In 1964 the Pet Food Institute started a campaign warning consumers about the dangers of feeding table scraps and the importance of feeding processed food to pets.⁸ Dry foods especially were marketed to the owner through a myriad of shapes and colors and catchy names. The next big change came with the marketing of "prescription" foods, sold primarily through veterinarians. This was initially done by Hill's® (which was purchased by Colgate Palmolive® in 1976) after their parent company had enormous success marketing toothpastes through dentists.⁹ Part of the message in this kind of marketing was that pet food is complicated and best left to the "professionals" who were the only ones who knew what pets really needed to eat.
Pet food manufacturers are regulated at the federal level by the FDA, under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act ( FFDCA). Within the FDA, the Center for Veterinary Medicine ( CVM) is responsible for the regulation of animal feed products, although they do not set any standards for pet food, and only regulate animal drugs, medicated feeds (which are almost entirely for livestock) and food additives. There is no pre-market approval requirement for pet foods.¹⁰
The FDA fulfills its mandate for pet food regulation by partnering with the Association of American Feed Control Officials ( AAFCO), "an organization almost entirely independent of government control." AAFCO has no enforcement authority and does not perform any analytical testing on pet food. A pet food manufacturer is only required to comply with the pet food regulations of the state in which it manufactures or sells its products.¹¹
The raw food movement is not new. There are plenty of people out there who have been raw feeding their cats — and dogs — successfully for decades. There are a growing number of small companies, frequently small natural or organic farmers working on a local level, that are filling the demand by pet owners for a healthier and more natural way to feed their animals. With the massive recent pet food recalls fresh in many people's minds, there has been increased interest in knowing what goes into commercial pet food, and many are questioning whether we are feeding our pets properly. Faced with the myriad of choices available, it's no wonder that people don't know what the best way to feed their pets is. Given that almost every veterinary office is filled with "prescription" foods promoted by a few large companies, asking your veterinarian for advice on proper nutrition may not get you an unbiased opinion. It's up to each person to educate themselves on their choices, and make up their own minds as to what to feed their pets. Taking control of what goes into your pet is an empowering experience.
For more details read Justine Patrick's excellent piece on pet food regulation. An informative book on manufactured pet food is Not Fit for a Dog! by Michael Fox, Elizabeth Hodgkins and Marion Smart. For an eye opening look at the more unsavory side of pet food manufacture, read Ann Martin's book Food Pets Die For.