Thiamine in a Raw Meat Diet

Answers: Thiamine in a Raw Meat Diet

There have been recent recalls of thiamine-deficient canned cat food. Is a raw meat diet safe from being thiamine deficient since it's not cooked?
 
In the past five years, there have been many recalls of commercial pet foods for various reasons. Five of these recalls have been related to the diets being deficient in thiamine, also known as vitamin B1. At least three of these recalls involved canned food.¹ None of these diets have been raw commercial diets.
 
Thiamine is a water soluble B vitamin important for helping the body to utilize carbohydrates as energy through a process called the TCA cycle. Thiamine is a necessary cofactor involved in this energy producing process. It is especially important for healthy functioning of the nervous system and heart. Deficiency of thiamine can cause neurologic signs, abnormal heartbeats, and gastrointestinal signs.² Thiamine is naturally found in various food sources some of which include whole grains and vegetables, legumes, and brewer's yeast. But, it is also present in muscle tissue of animals, particularly in the liver and heart. The mere presence of thiamine in a food may not correlate with its activity or bioavailability. Several factors may affect the bioavailability and/or activity of thiamine in processed foods. As much as 50% to 100% of the thiamine present in raw meat can be inactivated by one or more of the following processing methods: heat, high amounts of sulfur based food preservatives, i.e. sulfur dioxide, and certain thickening additives in canned foods which may alter the pH of the food.³
 
Raw meat diets are not exposed to heat as canned and dry diets are, therefore the thiamine in these diets remains intact. These diets also do not use any of the additives or preservatives used in canned foods.
 
Dogs and cats are unable to produce adequate amounts of thiamine and therefore need to consistently consume it in their diet. Cats require three times as much thiamine in their diet as dogs do. The recommended daily allowance of thiamine per day for cats is 0.33 mg. Note that this is for an approximately 250 kilocalorie diet, which is about what a 9 pound cat would eat per day. A cat will typically eat about 4 to 5 ounces of meat per day. As you can see from the chart, you can easily meet the minimum RDA for thiamine by feeding a variety of meats and including hearts and liver. Plus, you can be certain that the thiamine in this diet has not been inactivated by processing. Many commercial raw diets either contain significant amounts of liver and heart or may have added nutrient supplements in them.
 
There are certain species of fish and shellfish that contain an enzyme called thiaminase which inactivates thiamine. However, the species known to contain this enzyme are generally not used in any of the commercial raw diets. Most of the fish in raw diets is either salmon or cod which do not contain thiaminase. For a complete list of fish and shellfish that do and do not contain thiaminase you can turn to this website.
 
Raw meat diets also have little to no carbohydrate content. This type of diet requires less thiamine because there is little to no need for carbohydrate metabolism and therefore much less requirement for the enzyme involved in the TCA cycle. High carbohydrate diets such as most dry and canned cat foods require more thiamine as it will need to be used in large amounts to metabolize the carbohydrates.
 
The bottom line is that raw diets are safe when done properly either by using a commercially prepared and balanced diet or by diligently making sure to take the steps to balance a homemade diet, either through use of individual supplements or prepared pre-mixes intended for use with raw meat.
 
I encourage anyone considering a raw diet for their cat to take the plunge. You will see some amazing changes in your kitty when it is done properly.
 
Note: Feline Nutrition provides feline health and nutrition information as a public service. Diagnosis and treatment of specific conditions should always be in consultation with your own veterinarian. Feline Nutrition disclaims all warranties and liability related to the veterinary advice and information provided on this site.
 
If you have a question, please send it to 5c8140889285865d428d81898c948f5a818e93978592936086858c898e858e9594928994898f8e868f958e848194898f8e4e8f9287425e818e93978592936086858c898e858e9594928994898f8e868f958e848194898f8e4e8f92875c4f815e4e hVVsyua59TDPMVA9hZSGME276v47GSVy caesar This page part is protected against spam bots and web crawlers. In order to be displayed you need to enable Javascript in your browser, and then reload the page. While we cannot answer questions individually, if your question would be helpful to others, we may post it in Answers.
 
Dr. Elisa Katz, DVM, is a graduate of Ohio State University and is the owner of Natural Pet Animal Hospital in Bourbonnais, Illinois. She practices holistic and integrative medicine focusing on proper diet and nutrition. Dr. Katz shares her home with four kitties and one dog.
 
  1. US Department of Health and Human Services, FDA, Recalls and Withdrawals.
  2. J Markovich, C Heinze and L Freeman, "Thiamine Deficiency in Dogs and Cats," Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 243, no. 5, Sept 1, 2013, 649-656.
  3. Markovich et al, "Thiamine Deficiency in Dogs and Cats."
  4. Markovich et al, "Thiamine Deficiency in Dogs and Cats."
  5. "Your Cat's Nutritional Needs, A Science-Based Guide for Pet Owners," National Research Council of The National Academies.
  6. M Lichtenberger, "Thiaminase and its Role in Predatory Pet Fish Nutrition," Wet Web Media. 2011.
  7. J Markovich, C Heinze and L Freeman, "Thiamine Deficiency in Dogs and Cats," Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 243, no. 5, Sept 1, 2013, 649-656.
 
Data used in the chart derived from USDA Agriculture Research Service, USDA National Database for Standard Reference.
FelineNutrition Feline Nutrition Answers: The Stomach Contents of Prey. https://t.co/XjPLK7JVAd
FelineNutrition Feline Nutrition Answers: Are Exotic Meats Nutritious or a Novelty? https://t.co/fuxQkZUSMi
FelineNutrition What's in Your Freezer? Safe Handling Practices. https://t.co/Sx9LPFG5p2
FelineNutrition Feline Nutrition Answers: What Exactly is an "Obligate Carnivore?" Cats aren't the only ones. https://t.co/SH0gV1yfiZ

Home

Nutrition

Health

Answers

One Page Guides

Features

Blogs

Membership

Feline Nutrition Foundation

Media/Press

About

Resource Center